Sponsor




Columns

GRAPEVINE - The Ravens Projected Final 53

Take I
Written By:  
The Ravens Projected Final 53

Quarterbacks (2): Joe Flacco, Marc Bulger

Analysis: The Ravens have too much talent at other positions, players more worthy of a roster spot than a third string quarterback. Let’s not get too carried away and conclude that the team’s wildcat options disappear with Troy Smith’s departure. When were those options ever used in a plus way against a difficult opponent? Truth be told, a quarterback of Smith’s caliber can be found atop the scrap heap of quarterbacks anytime, anywhere, any day. Even Smith might be the one down the road (if needed) atop that heap. After all the former Heisman winner apparently attracts little interest around the league. Even the Browns opted for the mighty Seneca Wallace over Smith preferring instead to hold on to their sixth round pick.

Running Backs (4): Ray Rice, Willis McGahee, Le’Ron McClain, Jalen Parmele

Analysis: Curtis Steele needs some seasoning and Coach Wilbert Montgomery has been working with him to change up his pacing, to let plays develop and not always go at top end speed. Steele has explosiveness in short spaces and if he can make special teams contributions he has a shot. Matt Lawrence who was among the final 53 in ’09 has yet to take the practice field and looks like an injury settlement waiting to happen.

Tight Ends (3): Todd Heap, Ed Dickson, Dennis Pitta

Analysis: This may be the easiest position on the team to assemble. 2009 fifth round draft pick Davon Drew has no chance to make this squad and looks like a wasted pick than no one in the organization wants to take credit/blame for.

Wide Receivers (5): Anquan Boldin, Derrick Mason, Mark Clayton, Donte Stallworth, Demetrius Williams

Analysis: Williams is among the five to make the final 53 based purely (at this time) on the number of reps he was given with the second team offensive unit v. the Panthers. This spot is still far too close to call. Williams’ primary threat looks like rookie David Reed with Justin Harper and Marcus Smith a distant 7 and 8.

Offensive Linemen (9): Jared Gaither, Ben Grubbs, Matt Birk, Marshal Yanda, Michael Oher, Chris Chester, Oniel Cousins, Tony Moll, David Hale

Analysis: Hale is far from a lock. No one has really stepped up for the ninth roster spot on the O-Line and it's not necessarily a given that 9 is the number. Stefan Rodgers has looked decent at times during camp but looked lost against Carolina. Joe Reitz has some upside (accept in his vertical leap) but might be a better practice squad option. Bryan Mattison is heady in the way you might expect from a coach’s son (Greg Mattison) but he lacks size and explosiveness. Ramon Harewood will not be released. He could end up on the final 53 man roster but he’s more likely to come up with a mysterious injury that will land him on IR in the same way that Tony Pashos did during his rookie season.

Defensive Linemen (7): Haloti Ngata, Kelly Gregg, Trevor Pryce, Cory Redding, Terrence Cody, Kelly Talavou, Lamar Divens

Analysis: Unless they can pull off a trade the Ravens will lose a quality defensive lineman who can be productive in a D-Line rotation. Talavou, Divens, Brandon McKinney and Art Jones are all very close. The Ravens could try to find a way to have 8 defensive linemen if they don’t make a trade or someone like Jones could also get the “Pashos treatment.”

Linebackers (10): Ray Lewis, Terrell Suggs, Jarret Johnson, Brendon Ayanbadejo, Dannell Ellerbe, Tavares Gooden, Jameel McClain, Antwan Barnes, Paul Kruger, Prescott Burgess

Analysis: This position looks fairly set but the tenth slot boils down to Burgess and Jason Phillips. Burgess has been a plus contributor on special teams and plays the weak side position while Phillips is an inside backer where the team seems pretty set with Lewis, McClain, Ellerbe and Gooden. Phillips will need to really impress special teams coordinator Jerry Rosburg. Ayanbadejo hasn't practiced yet and PUP is a possibility which could free up a spot for Phillips or a contributor at another position. Should Sergio Kindle make a remarkable recovery he could alter the make up of this unit. At this point Kindle looks to be a lock for the PUP List but word is that the Ravens view this as the most optimistic outlook for the former Longhorn. Kindle is still without a contract and will not get one until he is medically cleared to play football.

Secondary (10): Ed Reed, Dawan Landry, Tom Zbikowski, Haruki Nakamura, Fabian Washington, Lardarius Webb, Chris Carr, Ken Hamlin, Cary Williams, Travis Fisher

Analysis: Fisher at this time seems to be a safe choice given his experience and number of reps with the first unit throughout camp. If not for injury and Williams' lack of availability in weeks 1 & 2, Fisher would be in jeopardy. That said he is hardly safe. Prince Miller gained some fans with his play against Carolina but he lacks size and isn’t as physical as a similarly sized predecessor, Corey Ivy. The Ravens ask their nickel to blitz on occasion. It would be difficult to envision Miller bringing down Ben Roethlisberger. Chris Hawkins could step up and there’s always the chance the team could make a deal for another corner. KJ Gerard showed promise during OTA’s but he’s been mostly a spectator during camp, slowed by a hamstring injury. Nakamura’s productivity could threaten Hamlin’s spot on the team if Reed does not go on the PUP list. Doug Dutch is purely a warm body to eat up practice reps.

Special Teams (3): Billy Cundiff, Morgan Cox, Sam Koch

Analysis: The Ravens would love to have a kicker who can nail an occasional 50+ yarder and history suggests that Shayne Graham is more likely to provide that ability. But Graham has so far lacked Cundiff’s consistency and one has to wonder if Graham has a bit of a kicker’s hangover after his playoff struggles last season as a member of the Cincinnati Bengals.

 

Post your comment

Your Name:
Your Email:
Your Comment:
Tony Lombardi
Posted On: 8/16/10 9:57 am
@ Richard...

I like Reed and I do believe that we've seen what we're going to see from Williams. But I'm basing this purely on the number of reps Williams gets in practice AND the fact that he saw way more time with Bulger than Reed.

So based on that, I'd say he's ahead.
Ravens_Flock
Posted On: 8/16/10 4:59 am
Good annalysis man. I mostly agree with you, except for a few spots.

For one, at RB, I'm not sold on Parmele. He needs to show some more at kick returner, because right now, I think there's several good candidates who could field both kicks and punts. I'm sure it might be wise to keep 3 RBs and McClain as FB, but honestly, Curtis Steele could surprise people. We'll see.

As for WR, I think you're right. I'm glad someone of note in the sports media spectrum acknowledges what I've been saying all along: that those five, including Clayton and Williams, are going to make the team. Fact of the matter is, Clayton is still a very good WR. I think it's debatable as to whether or not he has the ability to live up to his draft pick spot, but regardless of semantics, the guy is a playmaker, and always has been. And as others have suggested, it did appear in that pre-season game that he does indeed play the slot very well. Especially if coverage is focused on guys like Boldin and Mason.

As for Demetrius Williams, let's be honest. The guy has had a damned hard time since coming to B-more. He had a reasonably great rookie season, especially down the stretch, and he looked like a stud at times. In fact, he looked like a stud the following two seasons, but unfortunately, never had the chance to continue fully developing as a playmaker, because he spent almost a full season between 2007-2008, injured. Which really sucks for him. I think he's still got as much promise now as he did when he was drafted, and quite frankly it gets a bit old when people say "he just hasn't taken advantage of his opportunities". What opportunities? He got injured his second and third seasons, and then last year, when he's finally healthy, the coaches choose Kelley Washington to take his #3 spot, even though Washington is certainly not the same kind of player Williams can be. And to make it worse, while active almost every game in 2009, he spent most of it just standing on the sidelines, twiddling his thumbs. He finally came in late in the season when Washington was hurt, and wouldn't you know it, he performed well. So again I ask, what opportunities did he have? Just imagine if he had been used all 2009, he could have had another full season to get experience in Cam's offense, and could have really made some plays and stretched the field for us, when we had hardly any deep game.

So yeah, I think Williams will win the fifth spot. Not just by default, mind you, but because he's got experience, he's shown he can make plays, he's improved his size and physicality, and I think he just brings more to the table than any of the other young guys at camp do. He's a different kind of player than Stallworth is, and it would be nice to have two legit deep threats in our arsenal, if we actually use them. That was one of our biggest problems last season, was Cam simply not making use of all the talent he had to work with. I also think Reed could lock up a #6 spot, as a ST player.

As for the other positions, I don't think we're going to wind up keeping 10 LBs. I think if any of those you mentioned go, it's going to come down to Burgess. Which sucks for him, but the other guys, I think, just have more to offer. I have a feeling that Kindle is going to wind up on IR, and I also still say what I've said for years now, that I think Barnes could be a future starter for us, when JJ is gone. The thought of a focused Suggs, and a more rounded Barnes as our OLBs, is definately an exciting thought, and I hope they use him a LOT more this year.

I also think Prince Miller has a shot to make this team, and am not sold on the Ken Hamlin making it, just because he's a veteran. I suppose it's going to come down to how likely it looks near Game 1, that Reed will be able to play this year. On the one hand, they need depth at safety if Reed isn't going to be able to play, but on the other hand, we need all the help we can get at CB, and maybe Miller could develop into a quality player. Who knows?

I also think McKinney makes the team over Divens. McKinney is a good player, he just needs to be a bit more aggressive. But the idea of having bodies like McKinney, Ngata, Gregg, AND Cody on a goal-line D, is very enticing. I think McKinney stays.

On a final note, I'm also glad you agree that Cundiff keeps his spot from last year. Graham may be a good kicker in the regular season, but we've all seem him choke at key moments in the past. Cundiff may not be great, but he was good enough last season to not LOSE us games, and if he can keep that up, then I think we're fine. I still wish we had Stover, but that's besides the point. As for Morgan Cox...I think it's a disgrace that the team cuts Katula after he's been a very solid LS for us for years. The issue he was having wasn't his fault last season, and putting our LS duties in the hands of a rookie who looked okay in one preseason game....I'm just feeling another Hauschka situation brewing. I think they need to reconsider, and bring Katula back, before he's signed to another team.

Go Ravens!
richard greenberg
Posted On: 8/15/10 10:14 pm
What's up w/DavidReed...you guys (the media) made him sound like the next JulianEdelman and now he's fighting for a roster spot?!?



«Go back to the previous page.
Written By:  

Polls

From the following list who will have the most sacks in 2012?


Twitter

Check us out on Twitter
  • 5/22/12: There's a Betemit Sandwich!
  • 5/22/12: Sox' Doubront reminds me of Andy Petitte

View all tweets & follow us!